One of the hardest transitions between casual churning and becoming a heavy hitter is the switch from earning miles and points to earning cash back.
The transition should happen when you’ve earned all the miles and points you can spend cover your travel for the next 12-18 months, because:
- Miles and points devalue by 30-50% in the span of years
- The programs with the best redemptions change over time
- Points don’t earn interest
- The value of an unredeemed point is zero
- Most of us don’t travel as much as we think we will (even if we travel a lot)
When you earn more points and miles than you can burn in a short time, the risk that excess points eventually become worth much less than when you earned them grows bigger than James’ Giant Peach from the famous historical documentary that I think is called “A kid finds a big fruit and someone wrote about it”.
Why do we fail to transition to cash back, even when we know analytically that it’s not the best option? The common answers I hear and that I’ve thought are:
- Points and miles are fun, pennies aren’t
- I’m motivated by travel, my job covers my cash needs
- What if me and six of my closest friends need to fly Lufthansa F on last minute notice to Frankfurt and I don’t already have the miles banked, and my 800,000 Membership Rewards won’t post for another week?
They’re all valid reasons, but seeing them written can help prevent you from falling into the same trap. Trust me, you don’t want to be down 100,000 Hawaiian miles that expired a few years ago because you didn’t ever have an actual use for them and weren’t active in the program; $1,000 would have been a lot better. #askmehowiknow
Happy Wednesday!
Nerds gonna nerd.